That
three out of eight volumes taken at random from the stack of
recent books of minor verse should have the root of the matter
in them, and one of the three in high degree of excellence, is a
very large proportion indeed. So far as the mere form goes, the
ephemeral verse of the day is undoubtedly on a high level. Most
of its professors can at least write smoothly, many even
musically; and though the volume of poetry was probably never so
great as now, the proportion of mere doggerel was probably never
so small. It is when we pass from the test of mere form and take
the greater test of substance that its insufficiency stands
revealed. It is a fairly common thing for educated people to be
able to write smooth verse; it is one of the rarest of human
attainments to have a direct personal knowledge and experience
of life coupled with the imaginative force that can transfigure
that knowledge into insight. That is the endowment of the poet
as distinguished from the easy practice of the versifier; and to
find evidence of it in any degree, however slight, in three
volumes out of eight is an unaccustomed proportion of grain to
chaff.
We must
ruthlessly exclude the first three authors on our list from any
part or lot in the poet’s endowment. They are hopelessly
commonplace; Mt. Hunt Jackson undisguisedly so, and Mr. Crowley
under a veil of mysticism that, being lifted, never by any
chance reveals a meaning worth the trouble of finding out. For
some of his verses we confess that we can find no meaning at
all, worthy or otherwise. Such conundrums as:
Apart, immutable, unseen,
Being, before itself had been,
Became. Like dew a triple queen
Shone as the void uncovered.
may have the
weight of deep philosophy in them, but to us they are uncommonly
like nonsense verse, reminding us more than anything else of
Lewis Carroll’s
’Twas
brillig, and the slithy tovos
Did
gyre and gymble in the wabe—
taken
seriously.
—The
Daily News,
21 July 1899.
______________________________
“Songs of
the Spirit,” by Aleister Crowley, evidently a poet of fine taste
and accomplishment. This booklet contains much that is
beautiful. (Kegan Paul, Pp. 109. 3s. 6d.)
—The
Outlook,
17 December 1898.
______________________________
By
a young author, as we guess, musical and mystical, full of too
vivid reminiscences of Swinburne, with sweeter inspirations of
Hood, the “Songs of the Spirit,” by Aleister Crowley (Kegan
Paul, Trench, Trübner and Co.) disclose much grace in thought
and in versification. They give hope that whenever he has
learnt a message fully worth delivering the author will speak it
with beauty and effect. The prettiest and most intelligible of
the collection of artistic little poems is, perhaps, “The
Violet’s Love-story.”
—Jewish
Chronicle,
30 December 1898.
______________________________
We imagine
Mr. Aleister Crowley, author of Songs of the Spirit (Kegan
Paul), to be a young man; evidently he is just passing through
the Swinburnian epoch. His verse is full of the influence of
“Poems and Ballads”; it contains a riot of words without much
thought at the back of them. We seem, for example, to have
heard this sort of thing a good many times before:—
The
garland I made in my sorrow
Was
woven of infinite peace;
The joy
that was white on the morrow
Made music of viols at ease.
The
thoughts of the Highest would borrow
The roar of the seas.
And
yet, despite a good deal of bombast about “lust being one with
love,” and the like, Mr. Crowley has many poetical qualities and
a great deal of promise. His muse is windy, and boyish in
over-emphasis, but he has a true sense of musical sound, and
metrically, he has scarcely a bad line. He should mature and
live to write very respectable verse. We doubt if he will ever
be original; but in the middle way of discipleship he ought to
do well enough.
—Literature,
6 May 1899.
______________________________
In the epilogue to his “Songs of the Spirit,” Mr.
Crowley tells us that
The garland I made in my sorrow
Was woven of infinite peace,
and he
prays that “for an hour Let my rhyme be not wholly unsweet.”
Nor shall it be, seeing how rich and melodious are many of his
poems, besides being full of powerful and original thought.
Their tendency is that of the occult philosophy, of a wild and
lurid colouring enough it may be, but in no instance devoid of
the marks of a true poetic imagination.
—The
Bookseller,
3 February 1899.
______________________________
This
modest little volume contains many beautiful thoughts expressed
in delicate phrases: daring verses too, which cannot lightly be
overlooked. “The Farewell of Paracelcus to Aprile,” “The
Initiation,” “The Philosopher’s Progress,” are finely-wrought
images from Mr. Crowley’s vivid mind. Little lyrics of sunshine
and wind; “Vespers,” with its chant-like march:
The
censer swings to slower time,
The darkness falleth deep;
My
eyes, so solemn and sublime,
Relent, and close, and weep:
And
on the silence, like a chime,
I heard the wings of Sleep.
“The Quest”
is another poem to ponder over, and to understand with
difficulty:
Now
backwards, inwards still my mind
Must track the intangible and blind,
And
seeking, shall securely find
Hidden in secret places
Fresh feasts for every soul that strives,
New
life for many mystic lives,
And strange new forms and faces.
Each page is
impressed with the stamp of an individual mind. Facing the
title-page is a verse from The Tale of Archais.
—The
Oxford Magazine, 29 November 1899.
______________________________
We shall be sorry if
anyone who cares much for verse in itself, who is curious of new
tendencies in contemporary poetry, and values the articulate
expression of an individuality, should miss a little book of
unusual quality, called “Songs of the Spirit,” by Aleister
Crowley (Kegan Paul and Co., 8vo., pp. 109, 3s. 6d.).
We have read it with admiration for its intense spirituality, as
well as for its technical superiorities, and with sympathy for
its spontaneous reflection of certain moods—byways of poetry, no
doubt, that Mr. Crowley pursues almost without variation except
in the movement of his rhythms, now swift as desire and now slow
as remorse, with an utterance at once mysterious and vivid.
Visions of temptation and of beatitude, wavering aspirations to
serenity and knowledge, hymns and rhapsodies of a devout
mysticity, emotional descriptions illustrating that saying of
Amiel’s, ‘Les paysages sont des états d’éme’—such are the
contents of this volume, in which we are sure of having heard an
impressive and an original voice dominating diverse echoes that
we hesitate whether to ascribe to literary influences or to
coincidence of temperament. For there are things that suggest
the names of Goethe and of Baudelaire; others such as “The
Quest” and that strange “Philosopher’s Progress” which begins
That which is highest as
the deep
Is fixed, the depth as
that above;
Death’s face is as the
face of Sleep;
And Lust is likest Lust,
share at least Blake’s impenetrable simplicity of form, and
their symbolism is, like his, curiously seductive, even where it
sems turned to obscurantism; elsewhere Mr. Swinburne is (if only
superficially) recalled; and “Vespers” is by no means unworthy
of Rosetti. Similar preoccupations, again, direct the muse of
Mr. Francis Thompson; but the verse of “Songs of the
Spirit”—essentially intimate , introspective if you like—is also
free from obvious artifice and eccentricity, it is fiery and
clear-measured and easy of phrasing. We venture to quote from a
poem dated “Amsterdam” some lines exemplifying Mr. Crowley’s
talent:
Let me pass out beyond
the city gate,
Where I may wander by
the water still,
And see the faint few
stars immaculate
Watch their own beauty
in its depth, and chill
Their own desire within
its icy stream.
Let me move on with
vacant eyes, as one
Lost in the labyrinth of
some ill dream,
Move and move on, and
never see the sun
Lap all the mist with
orange and red gold,
Throw some lank windmill
into iron shade,
And stir the chill canal
with manifold
Lays of clear morning;
never grow afraid
When he dips down beyond
the far flat land,
Know never more the day
and night apart,
Know not where frost has
laid his iron hand,
Save only that it
fastens on my heart;
Save only that it grips
with icy fire
These veins no fire of
hell could satiate;
Save only that it
quenches this desire.
Let me pass out beyond
the city gate.
We should like to give other examples, but we can only name some
of those pieces that seem to us most remarkable. Such are “An
Ill Dream,” of which the glowing imagery seizes and holds fast
the vagueness of shifting impressions; a “Farewell of Paracelsus
to Aprile,” containing some fine lyric flights; “The
Initiation,” and “Succubus,” a record of fearful obsessions in a
metre which, in spite of a few unaccountable lapses, we think
extremely effective.
—The Manchester Guardian, date unknown.
______________________________
“Songs of the Spirit,”
by Aleister Crowley, ascend, as the motto on the
title-page—“Sublimi feriam sidera vertice”—indicates, to higher
regions, which seem peopled with an unusual number of gory
phantoms. They are difficult to read, and where they touch
definite things more sensual than sensuous. A poet’s dreams are
not often so persistently full of “miasmal pestilence-light” as
these. We do not like “dawny” and “frondage,” and cannot say
these verses deserve to be read—sung they could hardly be.
—The Athenaeum, date unknown.
______________________________
Ambitious verse, which, if we are right in supposing it to be
the work of youth, enables us to predict excellent work from Mr.
Crowley when his philosophy of life has been matured.
—The Church Times, date unknown.
______________________________
Though we cannot identify ourselves with the sentiments
expressed in its pages, we must acknowledge that the poems show
very considerable literary merit.
—The Granta, date unknown.
______________________________
Mr. Crowley (who should
drop the dreadful fore-name with which he has been afflicted)
sings almost melodiously, if not always intelligibly and
sometimes nonsensically. There is too much of the cant of a
contest between earthly and heavenly love in his pages. Why any
such contest? Cannot the rose and the lily bloom side by side?
A book of wandering cries such as this we cannot regard as of
much significance. But we may hope that the author’s
indubitable singing power may gain an assured note with his
further development. We would advise him to be less
introspective and subjective and more objective and dramatic, to
seek less to express directly his own thoughts than to present
man and world in the light of his thoughts. This Spenserian
stanza is not unworthy of the author of “Adonais”:
So I press on, fresh
strength from day to day
Girds up my loins and
beckons me on high,
So I depart upon the
desert way,
So I strive ever toward
the copper sky,
With lips burnt black
and blind in either eye.
I move for ever to my
mystic goal,
Where I may drain a
fountain never dry,
And of Life’s guerdon
gather in the whole,
And on celestial manna
satisfy my soul.
—The Literary Gazette, date unknown.
______________________________
We have received for
review a little book of poems entitled “Songs of the Spirit,” by
Aleister Crowley, whose initials “A. C.” are not unknown to
readers of “The Cantab” and “The Grants.” Though we cannot
identify ourselves with the sentiments expressed in its pages,
we must acknowledge that the poems show very considerable
literary merit. Here is a description of the Cam:
The corpse-lit river,
whose dank vapours teem
Heavy and horrible, a
deadly steam
Of murder’s black
intolerable might.
—The Cantab, date unknown.
______________________________
Mr. Aleister Crowley has
merits as well as faults, although the latter are the more
patent. He lacks a sense of humour, but on the other hand he
has a high seriousness, which is full of promise, even if it be
a trifle ludicrous and monotonous.
—The J. C. R., date unknown.
______________________________
“Songs of the Spirit”
proves that Mr. Aleister Crowley has read his Swinburne.
Like snows on the
mountain, unlifted
By weather or wind as it
blows,
In hollows the heaps of
it drifted,
The splendour of
fathomless snows;
So measure and meaning
are shifted
To fashion a rose.
Mr. Crowley has a large
vocabulary and considerable metrical skill. At present he does
not seem careful to consider the meaning, and some of his pieces
are nearly akin to verbiage. He has imagination, however; and,
not infrequently, the poet’s touch.
—The St. James’s Gazette, 2 Mar 1899.
______________________________
A volume of very unequal
verse. There are exquisite stanzas here and there, and as a
whole, the book is above average, but there are many poor pieces
and many faults.
—The Bookman, date unknown.
______________________________
Mr. Aleister Crowley
(“Songs of the Spirit”) has a remarkable mastery of form:
Like snows on the
mountain, unlifted
By weather or wind as it
blows,
In hollows the heaps of
it drifted,
The splendour of
fathomless snows;
So measure and meaning
are shifted
To fashion a rose.
It is the very sound of
Mr. Swinburne; and the whole book is full of it. But Mr.
Crowley seems to have it by nature; his style would have been as
it is supposing Mr. Swinburne had never written; at any rate,
that is suggested by the ease and fluency of the measure.
—Mr. John Davidson in The Speaker, date unknown. |